If you've ever tried to buy a toy for a five-year-old, you know exactly how hard it can be. Not only do toys change with the times, but finding a toy that's suitable for someone's specific age and development can be an additional hurdle.
Sure, brick-and-mortar stores let you walk up and down aisles to find toys, but this can cost you a lot of time and money. Plus, you may still leave empty-handed.
This is where online toy store options come into play, and the American Toy Store has recently earned its flowers. That said, it helps to know more about this store before you purchase toys from it.
What's more, it helps to know if they're credible, what sets them apart, and how they compare to other options.
Thankfully, we have your back. We've done the research, and in this American Toy Store review, we cover everything you need to know about this popular toy company.

Jump to:
What Is the American Toy Store?
First and foremost, we have to introduce you to the American Toy Store. The American Toy Store is an online store that sells toys for children of all ages.
According to the store’s about page, its mission is to ensure that it has the best selection of toys for children around.
The team carefully curates a catalog of the best toys for kids of all ages, and the store focuses on keeping its inventory up to date with the latest trends.
The store is also simple to use and offers discounts from time to time. Plus, you can create an account to make shopping even easier. Ultimately, it's a simple online store that helps you find toys for children of all ages.
There are a few categories you can choose from, and the platform makes it easy to shop by gender, interests, and even by most popular.
The Highlights of Our American Toy Store Review
When it comes to American Toy Store, there are a lot of things that we love. Not only does the store have just about anything a kid could need, but it's also easy to shop at, with great categories and age-appropriate options. We cover some of our favorite things about the American Toy Store below.
The Selection
When you need to find the best toys, you really can't go wrong with the American Toy Store. We found that the catalog is current and includes some of the most popular toys around at affordable prices.
For this reason, you really don't have to go anywhere else to find what you’re searching for, and the catalog is updated frequently with new toys that are popular according to feedback and trends.
What's more, gift wrap options and cards are available to help you get all your holiday or birthday shopping done in one convenient place.
Shopping By Age
We have to talk about the store's whole shopping-by-age approach. If you've ever walked into a toy store, you know how hard it can be to find toys for children based on their age, because the selection tends to be a random assortment down every aisle.
The good news is that the American Toy Store doesn't make you go through this hassle at all.
To find toys for the age group you need, simply shop by age. You can start with baby toys, but then you can move on to every single age through their teen years. Sure, this might not sound big, but have you ever tried shopping for a six-year-old?
By knowing the kinds of gifts that fall into that age group, you'll have a much easier time showing up to any child’s birthday party or the holidays.
Gender Categories
One of the simplest features that the site offers is its gender categories. The store makes it hassle-free to shop for boys and girls.
There are sections for the most popular toys for each gender, and this applies to every age through a child’s teenage years.
When you're worried about making the right choice for a boy or girl, you can also view content written by the editorial team that further assists with narrowing down your options.
Collection Recommendations
One of our favorite features that the American Toy Store offers is its collections.
You'll find that the team consistently picks popular toys and offers them in groups for you to comb through. This makes it even easier to find the toys that you’re searching for.
For example, there is an entire collection dedicated to toys that encourage kids to play outdoors.
You'll also find additional options, like STEM gifts for kids, puzzle gifts for kids, and much more.
Overall, this makes finding what you’re searching for a breeze, especially if you’re shopping for a child that has some unique interests.
Shopping Assistance
Last but not least, we love the assistance that the platform offers for shopping.
The store uses a blog to help you narrow down your options and find the toys that you're looking for.
If you’re worried about something specific or want to learn more about how toys can help with a child’s development, this is where the blog comes into play and can help.
Ultimately, there are dozens of great articles that you can read, and they'll help you learn more about where kids are at in their development stage and how that impacts the toys they play with.
Aside from a blog, the team makes it easy to get your money back if you have any problems. Plus, some toys are available with same-day shipping.
Overall, we could really tell the American Toy Store team cares about their customers and the children they shop for.
Things to Consider About the American Toy Store
The American Toy Store is among the best places to shop for a child online. While we found a lot of great things about this store in our review, that doesn't mean it's perfect, and no store is.
The good news is that a lot of issues that we found are more like minor nitpicks rather than massive flaws. Learn more about some factors to consider about the American Toy Store below.
Lack of Real-Time Support
While the American Toy Store maintains great reviews and customer support, there is a lack of real-time support. In other words, you may have to wait a while to hear back from the team.
In fact, even something simple like a chatbot could help with the navigation process or with any shopping issues. Finding contact information can also be a little tricky.
While this may be the case, it's a smaller team than giants like Amazon or Walmart, and with such a great selection and a 30-day money-back guarantee, we don't mind giving them a little leeway there.
The About Page Is a Little Sparse
The about page doesn't offer a lot of information about the company. Sure, it covers the store’s mission statement and highlights their dedication to children and helping them find the right toys, but there really isn't anything else.
Unfortunately, this makes it hard to find details about when the store was founded and who's behind it.
While this doesn't matter too much when you’re shopping online, and you can always look at the hundreds of positive customer reviews to support that, we’re just saying that we want to know a little more.
Less Options Than Some of the Toy Giants
The American Toy Store makes it easy to find the toys you're looking for, and you'll find that it has a massive catalog of toys. However, it doesn't have as many toys as a larger supplier, like Walmart or Amazon.
This is due to the nature of those companies versus this one, especially when the American Toy Store favors quality over quantity.
While this can be a problem at times, the selection is great enough for you to never notice.
Plus, sometimes having refined options for each category makes it easier to make a decision because there's less to think about.
The Verdict of Our American Toy Store Review
When you want to buy toys online, you have a ton of options at your fingertips. From giants like Amazon to mom-and-pop stores, plenty of toy stores are out there.
So, how do you choose where to spend your time and money? Well, if you want to save on both, the American Toy Store is the best place to shop.
Our American Toy Store review found that it's one of the most affordable options to shop, but also one of the best places to find a gift.
With plenty of great categories, age groups, and hand-picked collections, you can't go wrong with this toy store.
Sure, it has some flaws, but most of them are the same issues you'll run into with any online store.
Overall, we can't recommend the American Toy Store enough.










Leave a Reply