Cut large heart shapes from the foam. You can do these in whichever colors you wish. Make them larger, so you can fit smaller hearts inside of them. To make our hearts nice and even, we folded the foam in half and cut out half of the heart to create two even sides.
Cut out your smaller accent hearts using the same method of folding and cutting. You want these to be slightly smaller so they fit inside the previously made hearts.
Add a dab of glue to the back of the smaller hearts and press them to the inside of the larger hearts.
Use two different coloured hearts when you do this step so you can see the way they complement each other. If you wish to add a third even smaller heart, go for it! Otherwise, proceed to the next step.
Attach the heart to the pencil. Glue it directly to the top of the pencilYour foam heart pencil toppers are now ready to be used!